Going Over Budget

On to Day 2! I’m excited, but still a little worried about making this budget work.

We stuck with our planned menu for meals and snacks throughout the day:

Shrimp Kabobs for dinner

Shrimp Kabobs for dinner

Breakfast (fruit) – .27
Morning snack (string cheese) – .25
Lunch (wrap sandwich) – 1.54
Afternoon snack (carrots and celery) – .35
Dessert (yogurt) – .58
Total daily meals/snacks (except dinner) – 2.99

But I didn’t budget for coffee, but I had one this morning. I made it at home for .78.

For dinner, we had kabobs. I bought a dozen shrimp because they were on sale. I used half of it on dinner tonight, so we each got a kabob with 3 shrimp. It’s definitely not enough protein, but I was nervous to buy any more than that. We also had a kabob of veggies (zucchini and onion) and a side of corn.

Here’s the cost breakdown:

6 shrimp – 1.73
1 zucchini – .59
1/2 onion – .20
2 ears of corn – 1.00
Total for dinner – 3.52

So our total for the day (meals and snacks during the day, my coffee, and dinner) came to $10.28, or $5.14 per person. We went over our budget for the day, but hopefully we’ll be able to make up for it somewhere.

Headaches & Lack of Energy

As my first day of the CalFresh challenge comes to an end, I would like to point out I have a headache and am drained-physically and mentally! I decided to buy groceriesyesterdayfor the first 3 days of the challenge- spent 13.50-and will purchasefood on Thursday for the last 4 days with the remaining balance.  I purchased bagged salad, bread, ham, bananas, cucumber, and avocado and plan to make it last for 3 days. I am planning to make identical meals for the next few days, so have averaged the price per meal. For breakfast I had a banana(.27 cents), salad for lunch (1.78) and sandwich (2.05). I had a cookie for dessert (.20 cents) and didn't factor my bottle of water into my budget today, so I know now for future purposes.

It was hard to focus at work; by 2 I was so tired and had no energy. My stomach was grumbling all day. It was hard for me not to buy anything, especially since I had money in my wallet. It took a lot of will power not to buy any snacks, and I am proud that I stuck to it. I think I will not be able to go for my 30 minute lunch walk, as I did not have the energy for it, so I have to consider that as well. I know it will be difficult this weekend as I have family visiting from out of town, but i will continue to try my best.

See you later Starbucks

CalFresh Challenge shopping in New York. 

CalFresh Challenge shopping in New York. 

First, It’s frustrating knowing that I will not be able to give myself to this challenge 100%. On Friday a dear friend is getting married and on Saturday I will be attending the Hudson Valley Garlic Festival. For a second, I thought about taking into account the cost per plate at the wedding reception hall, but at $66, I would be sacrificing TWO WEEKS of food. With regards to the Garlic Festival, this glorious event comes but once a year and is a shining beacon in my small life. To make amends for my deviance from the challenge I will attempt to stretch out the food I bought for the challenge for two days past the official end. 

Location might prove to be a challenge. I am a native San Diegan living in the Hudson River Valley of New York. For over three years the East Coast has been my home and for over three years the discrepancies between East Coast and West Coast food have been the bane of my existence. I shudder every time I look at the outrageous prices of avocados and citrus. And I always have to give my produce an even more careful once-over since fruit and veggies take a beating when trucked over from the Central Valley of California. When I get the chance, I try to hit up the local farms for produce, but since I work Saturdays, I can’t make the local Farmer’s Markets and the one grocery store that features local products is a thirty minute trek (one that I refuse to make during bitter winter days). In New York the average weekly food stamp benefits per participant is $36.93, but I’m sticking to the California budget. 

Food is an extremely social aspect of my life. My mid-morning coffee break I have at the office is such an essential part of my day and my mid-week happy hour adventure is key to keeping sane. I’ve already rescheduled Aside from the previously stated exceptions, I will only eat food I have prepared from the items I purchased for the challenge. See you later Starbucks. Take care Sam Adams…

1 package of corn tortillas- $1.29
2 cans of black beans- $.67 each
1 can of garbanzo beans- $. 67
Brown rice- $1.19
Quick Oats- $2.69
Balsamic vinegar dressing - $2.99
Kale bunch- $.95
2 lb package of carrots- $1.00
Garlic- $.50
3 Russet potatoes -$2.56
Cucumber -$.66
Sweet potato -$1.02
Onion -$1.21
4 Granny Smith apples - $3.03
Jalapeno pepper - $.22
Green pepper -$1.11
2 tomatoes- $3.17 

TOTAL with Tax: $25.40

Stress and Stigma

Around 2pm on Sunday I turned to my fiancé (E) and said, so we start the Challenge tomorrow and should probably have a game plan, huh?  He agreed, and we got to work.  Two hours later, E had looked at all of the local grocery store ads, and together we created a meal plan that we hoped provided enough nutrition and variety while staying within our ~$60 limit. 

It wasn’t easy. I’m gluten and soy intolerant, and we’re both used to eating out almost as much as we eat in.  We created a meal plan, and then a shopping list, and then cut back.  While we are generally a great team, there were multiple, “do we really need this?” and “how important is this, really?” and a few “why can’t you eat/like this?”  The tension in the house definitely rose as our anxieties about meeting our nutritional needs impacted the rest of our conversations.   A quick search pulled up multiple studies linking food insecurity to stress and domestic violence.  I thought about how stressful it would be to try and find meals that were nutritionally adequate, cheap and (and enjoyable ?!?) to everyone in the household as well as the likelihood that if I was struggling to purchase food, I’d also be struggling to make other critical purchases like paying rent/mortgage, putting gas in the car.  I quickly arrived at the realization that SNAP is only part of it; I’d be juggling competing priorities vying for time, brain space and patience.  While we were able to fairly quickly bounce back from our snappy “SNAP” conversation, the ability to do so partially hinged on the larger context of this experience’s time limit and gratitude that this does not have to be our daily experience.

On the way to the grocery store, E and I talked about how SNAP was meant to be a supplement and often becomes the primary food budget.  We also talked about the impact of SNAP on local economies.  E was surprised to learn that SNAP benefits are only distributed once per month during the first 10 days.  This morning, I came across an article talking about how hard it is for many grocers to keep up with the variable demand based on SNAP distribution. Apparently, some stores struggle to keep enough product,  leaving customers to go home empty handed… on the way to the store, little did I know how much this would affect me.

Once we got to the grocery store, a new set of conversations unfolded.  I had estimated how much each item would cost based on current purchasing patterns, and while I was close on most, a few items costed much more than expected.  We found ourselves in the meat department, debating about how much chicken to buy, when I looked at the expiration date and realized that the chicken wouldn’t make it all week.  My first thought was to just come back, but I realized that not only did we need food for Monday’s dinner, we probably shouldn’t be spending lots of gas money to go back and forth to the grocery store 10 times.  During this debate, the chicken was be “restocked.”  We awkwardly hung out in the meat section until the new food was out and dug into the “back” to find the meat with the latest expiration date.  It was $3.50 more than we budgeted because it was a bigger package… after more conversations, we took it and reduced our meal plan variety.  Lunches of Rice and Beans and Pad Thai just turned into Rice and Beans and Rice and Chicken.  On the way home I thought about all of our grocery store conversations and how lucky we were to never have to debate the legitimacy of one another’s purchases in public… upon sharing how conscious I was of our grocery store price conversations, E said he noticed other couples having similar conversations… even if no one else stalked the meat section for 10 minutes. 

Eating the Same Meals Every Day

Day 1 of the CalFresh Challenge. It took hours of planning to create a menu and shopping list for the week that doesn’t exceed the average CalFresh weekly benefit amount of $30.67/week. I can’t imagine how difficult this would be for an entire family. My groceries for the week totaled $29.64, primarily from North Park Produce, a small ethnic market in my neighborhood.  My plan is to eat almost the same thing every day:  lentils/rice or beans/rice, PB & J, and some fruits/veg.  It’s a healthy plan, but I know it would be almost impossible to get kids to adhere to a regimen like this.  

Convenience over Price

I did not spend a lot of time planning out my meals this week. As a previous SNAP/CalFresh recipient, I had some idea of what items I could use to plan out my meals. That’s not to say that the entire process was super simple and I did have to make some quick calculations in my head but I wanted to replicate how I would be making decisions if this was not the week of the CalFresh Challenge. Realistically, I would not spend hours making spreadsheets and calculating every penny.

As I stood in the aisle of the supermarket (I opted to go to Trader Joe’s because that was where I used to shop as a SNAP/CalFresh recipient and I knew the layout the best), I did mental math: yes, buying instant oatmeal in packets is more expensive than regular oatmeal and it has more sugar; however, I’ve never made oatmeal from scratch and I am not a morning person. Instant oatmeal won.

It wasn’t until I went home that I made a meal plan for the week. It looks like it will be a pretty repetitive week and I’ll need to return to the store later this week for eggs and lettuce but overall it seems like a good start for the week.

I do think that if this was the first time having to plan a meal with a limited budget, I would have found the process more stressful than I have so far. I am also very aware that the Challenge is only for a week. As someone who loves to eat out and drink Starbucks more often than I probably should, giving up these things for one week isn’t so bad; however, committing to giving up these “luxuries” for a more indefinite time would be challenging. 

Panic in the Grocery Store: My first day on food stamps

The heat in late September has been particularly brutal, even for San Diego where everyone expects warmth. As I walked into the cool, fresh air of the grocery store, I was expecting to feel relief, but instead panic set in: I was there to buy my groceries for one week of living on a food stamp budget, as part of the CalFresh Challenge, an awareness campaign my organization is running to shed light on issues surrounding food stamps for the hungry.

Erika's groceries for the week of the Challenge

Erika's groceries for the week of the Challenge

Even though I entered the grocery store ‘fully prepared’ with a menu for the week, I instantaneously started realizing that what I had planned did not match up with the mega sale items, and that I would need to rethink things. I recognized pretty quickly that planning the menu needed to go hand in hand with scanning the store’s weekly ad. As a married woman without any children and a full time job, this seems cumbersome. Imagine if you added children and grandparents and other mouths to feed into the equation. After spending an hour shopping for my week, some themes came to emerge:

  • The dissolution of choice

Instead of going around the store looking at what delighted my senses the most, I was instead drawn to the large orange sale tags underneath certain items. They became my focal point. If I had it in mind to buy spinach, but iceberg lettuce was on sale, then it was iceberg that was purchased. No longer was my meal based on nutrition or desire, it was based on what the weekly ad touted as the cheapest item.

  • Panicked decisions

I had planned a relatively nutritious menu for myself, but as I walked through the store, I started to feel like I was not getting enough, that I would be hungry, that I was staring down the barrel of famine. My purview changed from my usual feeling of excitement at the grocery store to sheer stress. I pictured myself on Thursday night feeling uneasy and voracious, so I began to buy “filler items” – foods that I knew would just satiate, and that had little nutritious value. This included 6 frozen burritos for $2.

  • Cheap food is cheap

Our government subsidizes farmers to grow corn and soy which are packed into billions of products with low nutritional value and low cost. There were tons of products I could buy at the store, but when it came to thinking through what would allow me to meet minimal governmental standards for nutrition, almost none of them fit the bill. Cheap food is cheap. So, while it may be filling and even fattening, it does not allow folks such as those on food stamps to lead an active, healthy life. Families often have to choose what will fill their childs’ bellies for the longest versus giving them something nutritious but leaving them hungry.

  • Repetition reigns

America is associated with variety and abundance and choice and freedom. When you’re living on $4/day, as millions of Americans are, all of that changes.  I will be eating the same thing for dinner, or some combination of the same ingredients, every night this week. Lunch and breakfast have a pretty similar look as well.

While I look forward to understanding what this reality is like for those that live it every day, I fully recognize that this snippet of time is in no way indicative of what this would be like to live on a food stamp budget year round. It would be an endless loop of stress, planning, anxiety, hunger, and malnourishment. Where food for so many is generally a source of pleasure, community-making, and fun, for those that stretch small amounts just to not go hungry, food is a source of anxiety and pain.

Get Ready for the CalFresh Challenge!

Hi CalFresh Challenge Participants!

Happy Friday! Thank you so much for signing up for the 2015 CalFresh Challenge! We’re thrilled to announce that elected officials Senator Ben Hueso and Assemblywoman Lorena Gonzalez will both be participating in the Challenge, along with Social Service Advisory Board member Carol Lewis and Kathlyn Mead, CEO of the San Diego Foundation!  

As you start thinking about next week's challenge, we wanted to share with you:

  • Quick video about SNAP/CalFresh facts
  • Shopping tips and sample meal plans for the CalFresh Challenge
  • Quick reminder to share your pictures and insights with us!
  • Invite you to our Fête to Fight Hunger event on September 30th

SNAP Facts vs. Myths
As you embark on the CalFresh Challenge, we think it’s important to have some information about the CalFresh/SNAP program! 

Shopping Tips and Meal Planning

An important part of the CalFresh Challenge is recognizing the challenging nature of meal planning. For tips and resources, please check out our “Tips” section on our site.

This year, we also have partnered up with an intern with UCSD Center for Community Health to create sample meal plans for the week of the Challenge that meet this year’s food budget of $30.67 per person and we are looking for help testing them out! Please consider using one of the following meal plans and let us know your thoughts!

Reminder to Share Stories!

One of the biggest pieces of the CalFresh Challenge is sharing your experiences with your friends and peers! We are looking for:

  • Pictures/short videos of your meals and experiences at the supermarket!
  • Submit your stories to us at marcia@sdhunger.org and we will post it on our blog. Please submit any blog entries or pictures by 10am and we will have them on our site by 1pm.
    • Entries should include what you ate, the cost of your meal, any challenges you encounter, physical or emotional experiences, and any insights you’re having.
    • For examples of our previous blogs, you can check out blog entries here!
  • Sharing any of your “aha! Moments” or other surprises with us through our Facebook and Twitter. This year, you can use the #CalFreshChallenge to share your experiences with other participants.

Consider Joining Us at our First Annual Fête to Fight Hunger!

Fête to Fight Hunger will be held on Wednesday September 30th from 5:30-7:30pm at Draft Republic in UTC. Please join us if you can to close out Hunger Action Month, share stories among those that took the CalFresh Challenge, and mingle with fellow anti-hunger advocates while enjoying some amazing food and drinks!
 
For tickets and information, please visit our event page. For those that are participating in the Peer to Peer fundraiser, if you are able to raise at least $100, you can attend the event for free!
 
Thank you again for taking the CalFresh Challenge! I look forward to hearing stories about your experience and to take the Challenge alongside all of you!

All the best,

Marcia